Home > Current Affairs, Politics - Domestic, The EYE-BALL Opinion > EYE-BALL Opinion – Cheap Wine No More – A blog respondent’s comments –

EYE-BALL Opinion – Cheap Wine No More – A blog respondent’s comments –

Latest ‘EYE-BALL Opinion’ Posts:

– 15th Oct – The Future – Welfare Raised Children – Government making it harder for Society to survive –

– 14th Oct – I am OFFENDED – All Australia is OFFENDED – why would it matter if PM Gillard is OFFENDED –

– 10th Oct – The Misogynist v Misandrist debate – there can be no winner and Society loses –

– 10th Oct – The Circus that never ends – Problem is nobody is buying tickets –

– 8th Oct – Carr’s Lunacy – Suggests Assassination to end Syria’s Civil War –

– 6th Oct – Gillards Culpability – On the ropes but nobody is game to deliver the knockout blow… –

– 5th Oct – Abbott’s Desperation – he thinks it’s a popularity contest –

– 3rd Oct – Gillards Legacy – Examples of Lunacy, Desperation and Stupidity –

– 25 Sept – The vacuum of Politics – do they ever listen to or watch replays of themselves?

– 25th Sept – Alas, Hedley Thomas has returned – Not to Sink Gillard, but to sink Campbell Newman’s Wivenhoe Dam coverup –

– 25th Sept – At the Risk of being called a Misogynist Sexist Nutjob Blogger – Women in Politics is the greater risk …

– 4th Sept – An Education Perspective – governments fail to grasp the reality of societal changes –

– 31st Aug: – Afghanistan – A Soldiers Sacrifice – a bottomless pit of Sacrifices –

– 30th Aug: – US Elections – The Republican Derby – The Joke is on all Americans … and Us –

– 30th Aug: – Wayne Swan – Just can’t help himself – A little man in every way –

– 27th Aug: – PM Gillard: do you recall ‘WATERGATE’ – it took Nixon two years to finally crack –

– 25th Aug: – Hedley Thomas – Australian Hero – Journalist story calls media to account –

– 24th Aug: – Duchess Julia can’t escape her past – News Journalist has the scent –

– 23rd Aug: – The Prime Minister Does not get it – Her Leadership has never been legitimised –

– 24th Aug: – Misogynist Nutjob’s – Protesters by another name –

– 23rd Aug: – Prime Minister Shines – stares down her detractors –

– 23rd Aug: – New CYBER DATA Laws passed – this is not the last word –

– 22nd Aug: – The Last Word on Copyright Piracy – News Ltd Chief shows ignorance –

– 21st Aug: – Julian Assange – The sage continues –

– 20th Aug: – Gillard’s PM tenure, All but over – She needs to learn a lesson from Nixon –

– 18th Aug: – Telstra-Bigpond – A protected Corporate species … WHY? – Part 1 – Telstra-Bigpond Billing Problems –

– 17th Aug: – The Julian Assange saga – the World should be concerned –

– 16th Aug: – The Asylum Seeker Solution – MP’s should hang their heads in shame

– 15th Aug: – Gillard – beyond redemption III – Pickering’s Offerings –

– 14th Aug: – Gillard – beyond redemption II – More from Alan Jones and Mike Smith –

– 13th Aug: –  Gillard – beyond redemption I – the walls are about to come dawn –

To see more EYE-BALL ‘Opinion’ posts:

click here …

– Cheap Wine No More  –
– A blog respondent’s comments –
| Author: EYE-BALL Opinion | 16th Oct 2012 |
News that the Government is going to try and address the alcoholism problem in disadvantaged communities by forcing up the cost of ‘cheap wine’ met with a response from a regular commentator who wanted his retort published …

Some background – a News Ltd story on the policy can be read here … and the actual report from the Australian National Preventative Health Agency (ABPHA) can be read here

The comment in its entirety is posted below:

How stupid and intrusive can government’s possibly get?

The latest outrage is a plan by Australia’s health do gooders’ to raise taxes on cheap wine so irresponsible..(read young people or is it really you and me) will stop getting drunk on it.

Using terms they must have learned from someone in commerce (read “the real world”), the Australian National Preventative Health Agency wants to establish a ‘floor price’ for cheap wine. Who is this agency and how come it even exists, can you believe there even is such an agency, and that we are paying for it? This is another example of why unemployment is understated, talk about jobs for the unemployable?

But that is not the point. The main point is that the agency should butt out of people’s private lives. One of life’s great pleasures is cheap wine. This is life. We have to have some comfort given the crap we have to put up with from our governments (governance)!

This agency is worried about the harmful effects of drinking too much cheap wine and pricing is, ‘recognised as one of the most effective measures to reducing alcohol-related harm.’ I wonder if they used the same team to establish what 85% of males think about the most? As much as I would like to congratulate them on this stupendous insight, the best I can say is, ‘Doh!’

Of course making things more expensive discourages people from buying them. In this case, the Government (but who are they really?) want to put the cheap wine makers out of business to save the people who didn’t ask for any saving. But if they take cheap wine into oblivion, the truly hard up will find a substitute. Rubbing alcohol, mouthwash, and moonshine are just a few. Who are these people kidding, do they think that an underground of sly grog will not open up and that they will cause a similar situation to the backyard amphetamine industry. We will all be buying wine making kits!

But the principle of the thing is what matters here. Using the tax system to coerce people into behaviour to think they should be following isn’t just busy-body meddling, it’s an affront to freedom in our society. It’s always done in the name of your best interests. But it always results in having less choice, more rules to follow, and higher taxes to pay. God only knows we have enough dysfunctional government and people within it, do we need this as well!!

What we ought to do is abolish the Australian National Preventative Health Agency and use the money saved to buy everyone a drink. Then we can all toast to being adults, living with our own choices, being responsible for our own actions, and enjoying as much wine as we like before we all die. I’ll drink to that!

David the Pragmatist!

PS Stand up and be counted and voice your protest to these faceless bastards!!!

Thankyou David for the comments.

Prohibition failed in the 1920’s to address the alcohol issues of the day – and since then Governments have nursed the main causes of societies major health issues – i.e. tobacco and alcohol, as foundations to a tax revenue system that falls far short of the health costs to deal with the end result.

Pushing up the price of ‘cheap wine’ is a policy decision long on intent, but far short of logic and history’s perspective.

As with excise duty on fuel, the higher the price the higher Federal and State revenues, they have no vested interest in keeping the cost of fuel low, or reducing the excise tax to a ‘cap’ system.

One has to venture in and ask, is a reduction in alcohol excise a part of the price increase, I dare suggest it is not so in any increased wine cost, Government’s increase their tax collect.

The targeted market this policy is targeting is interesting – David the Pragmatist’s comments obviously interfere with the costs of his lifestyle and many others who drink wine as an alternative to other forms of alcohol. One needs to read the Legislation to find out more before an opinion can be offered. but like all things, apathy is the enemy. Most will just pay the additional cost and forgo some other expense as a result.

The over-riding question is the motive behind the policy to push up alcohol prices, is it some moderised ‘Temperance League’ movement?

Please – if you found this story to your liking and would like to promote it to your social media contacts – i.e. Twitter, Facebook, or other icon linked account below – please click your favoured Icon(s) to promote the story.


Have your say where it counts: – contact your Local Federal Representative via the links below and let them know how you feel about this, or any other topic that you feel strongly about – or you can just post a comment below and let off some steam.

Links to Australian Parliamentary Website – MP’s

The EYE-BALL Opinion …

  1. Brian former Hotelier
    October 16, 2012 at 10:25 am

    This article is so to the point. If you read Paul Syret’s column in the Courier Mail today you will see some further startling statistics. Do you know that bottled water is more expensive than Petrol?
    Come on give us a go, I agree with the writer, who are these bastards?, if they want to stop young people drinking, raise the age limit to 21. In my case they can raise it to 50, but that wouldn’t be fair to all the drunken 45 year olds in our society.

  2. October 17, 2012 at 6:04 am

    Welcome to the brave New World of the Greens and other control freaks pushing the UN Agenda 21 one world government. Total control over everything you do say or think is the object, all wrapped up in high-sounding motives. Wait till you’re all issued with your own personal carbon credit cards! People will look at each other and say – how the hell did we let this happen. Have a look at the crazy policies of some of your local councils where killjoy Greens have infiltrated and seem to be allowed to dominate. Look up Agenda 21 on the internet and see what’s in store for Australia and the world if these would-be dictators get their way!

  1. No trackbacks yet.
Comments are closed.
%d bloggers like this: